I am so experienced in asking why that I have a thousand synonymous ways of posing the question. Sometimes I think I am asking something else entirely, but always, it can on some level be reduced to that age-old toddler's lament of 'why, why, why?' Why my son? Why that day? Why are we even here? Why do we bother living when we know that we must die? Why do people keep wanting to minimise my loss? Why didn't I take more photos of him? Why didn't I spend more time with him in the hospital? Why didn't I undress him and commit to memory every inch of his little body? Why can't anyone help me? Why can't I remember? Why can't I forget?
Those are just the big questions, of course. They are the umbrellas under which hover hundreds of tinier, but no less distressing, 'whys'. Why do I still have to put petrol in the car? Why must I feign happiness at the news of other people's pregnancies? Why must they keep on announcing to me their pregnancies? Why I am so hungry? Why am I so tired? Why is my kitten continually pissing on all of my belongings?
Those are daily, run of the mill 'whys' I have to deal with all the time, and they are perhaps more draining than any of the existential ones I could pose to you.
Melanie and I often discuss books. She reads about as voraciously as I do. We read a lot of the same things. She told me she had just read The Beginner's Goodbye by Anne Tyler, which gently probed many of the same questions we'd been discussing. Such is the size of my unread bookshelf, and my obsession with purchasing books online, that I didn't realise that I'd already bought a copy of this same book. I got it out when I arrived home, and I sat and read it in one sitting. Yes, it spoke to me. A simple, kind of suburban, domestic, homespun narrative, typical of Tyler's novels, that dealt with some of the biggest, and perhaps most absurd, of life's questions.
The defining question of the book, I suppose, is what it means to be dead - both for the dead person and the loved one left behind. Aaron, a 37 year old editor, loses his wife in a freak accident when an oak tree crashes through his sun room, causing a heavy old Sony Trinitron television to fall on her and flatten her chest like a tack. There's humour in there too. If only, Aaron desperately laments, they'd decided to buy a flat screen TV, which would have been significantly lighter and less chest-crushing. For a time, all of his thought space is taken up with seemingly comical, but in fact very serious questions like this. I can relate to the peculiar sense of reasoning Aaron engages in ('If we had had a flat-screen TV, would Dorothy still be alive?'); it doesn't seem at all peculiar to you when you're trying to figure out what the hell bomb just went off in your life. Aaron's first thought is about the TV, but he doesn't stop there. Would she still be alive. . .
If her patient hadn't cancelled. Then she wouldn't even have been home yet when the tree fell.'But no, no,' he says. 'I had to stomp off in huff and sulk in the bedroom, as if it had mattered in the least that she'd refused to settle for Wheat Things.' It is the absurd unpredictability of life, the realisation that such a small, domestic trifle as a misplaced packet of biscuits could have such profound life or death consequences, that leaves Aaron in a vicious cycle of trying to make meaning from the ultimately meaningless. The novel asks: how do you make sense of a loss caused by a convoluted series of entirely unnecessary and preventable events? And Aaron answers that you don't, and that the worst part of this is that you are doomed to just keep on analysing the minutia, looking for that split second or that tiny action or word that could have stopped the disaster in its tracks. If only you'd realised what it was all adding up to. If only.
Or if she had stayed in the kitchen instead of heading for the sunporch.
If I'd said, "Let's see if I can find those Triscuits," and gone out to the kitchen to help her look, and then sat with her at the kitchen table while she ate them.
The question of what it means to be dead takes on a whole new meaning when Aaron's dead wife, Dorothy begins appearing to him many months after she died . The opening line of the novel is just undeniably wonderful and illustrates how, when you're mired in grief, everyone else seems like they're mad because they're not complicit in your 'reality'. You feel like you're the only one in the world who's actually truly alive - electrically alive, and that everyone else is just a plastic soldier or something, looking the part, but not really participating in your war. Aaron narrates:
The strangest thing about my wife's return from the dead was how other people reacted.He has already confronted a thing he thought impossible - the loss of his wife - so I guess it doesn't seem much of a stretch to accept that something else as implausible as her return could happen. "Put yourself in my place," he says.
Call to mind a person you've lost that you will miss to the end of your days, and then imagine happening upon that person out in public. You see your long-dead father sauntering ahead with his hands in his pockets. Or you hear your mother behind you calling, "Honey?" Or your little brother who fell through the ice the winter he was six, let's say, passes by with his smell of menthol cough drops and damp mittens. You wouldn't question your sanity, because you couldn't bear to think this wasn't real. And you certainly wouldn't demand explanations, or alert anybody nearby, or reach out to touch this person, not even if you'd been feeling that one touch was worth giving up everything for. You would hold your breath. You would keep as still as possible. You would will your loved one not to go away again.Dorothy appears increasingly as time goes on and Aaron is constantly struck at people's refusal to acknowledge that Dorothy is there walking right alongside him. They
pretended not to recognize either one of us. They would catch sight of us from a distance, and this sort of jolt would alter their expressions and they would all at once dart down a side street, busy-busy, much to accomplish, very important concerns on their minds.Ah, I thought, when I read this: the contagion of the bereaved. I recognise that. I've felt it myself at times. Though no one has knowingly avoided me on the street, plenty have done the exact same thing in pretending nothing has happened or changed when they do see me, instead babbling on inanely about their kitchen renovations and designer bench tops, which is insulting and absurd in equal measure. Though I'm not accompanied by the corporeal presence of my dead baby in my dealings with the world as Aaron seems to be with Dorothy, I might as well be sometimes for the extent to which people fear conversing with the acutely bereaved. That's what Aaron's saying, too, I think.
![]() |
| Aaron feels like he and Dorothy are the only two people really alive |
The casseroles started thinning out and the letters stopped. Could people move on that easily? Yes, well, of course. New tragedies happened daily. I had to acknowledge that. It seemed heartless that I should think to go in for my semi-annual dental checkup, but I did. And then I bought myself some new socks. Socks, of all things! So trivial!As time passes, Aaron says that 'more and more often I could hear my sister thinking, It's too bad his wife had to die, but was she really worth quite this much grief? Does he have to go on and on about it? There's that pressure - real or perceived - to stop holding people back with your sorrow. Sometimes it feels ever-present. But the desire to see you 'healed' is often a selfish one, borne out of compassion fatigue, or guilt, or perhaps a person's own suffering at watching someone they love suffer so.
But, of course, time is meaningless to the grief monster. Even when Aaron thinks he is over the worst of it, seeming 'unknowingly to have traveled a little distance away from that first unbearable pain', there's some mornings he wakes up with in a panic, thinking he hasn't heard from her in a while, before he has to realise all over again,
Oh. She's dead. And it wasn't any easier than it had been at the very beginning. I can't do this, I thought. I don't know how. They don't offer any courses in this; I haven't had any practice.While for the most part Aaron feels like "the grief has been covered over with some kind of blanket. It's still there, but the sharpest edges are . . . muffled, sort of", every now and again he lifts a "corner of the blanket, just to check, and - whoa! Like a knife!'. He says, resignedly, I'm not sure that will ever change."
Really, I had made no progress whatsoever.
And does it change? Well, I don't want to entirely spoil the story. I'd like you to read it for yourself, and tell me what changes, and what stays the same for Aaron, and by extension, what we can hope for all of us who have lost a dear loved one and can't bear to imagine what the future may hold.


No comments:
Post a Comment
Thank you for visiting my blog. Please feel free to share your thoughts or feelings, big or small, with me here.