Monday, May 28, 2012

Poem on the death of an infant

Here is the second poem I mentioned in my previous post. 

A Funeral Poem on the Death of C. E. an Infant of Twelve Months

Phillis Wheatley (1753–1784)


THROUGH airy roads he wings his instant flight
To purer regions of celestial light;
Enlarg’d he sees unnumber’d systems roll,
Beneath him sees the universal whole,
Planets on planets run their destin’d round, 
And circling wonders fill the vast profound.
Th’ ethereal now, and now th’ empyreal skies
With growing splendors strike his wond’ring eyes:
The angels view him with delight unknown,
Press his soft hand, and seat him on his throne;
Then smiling thus. “To this divine abode,
The seat of saints, of seraphs, and of God,
Thrice welcome thou.” The raptur’d babe replies,
“Thanks to my God, who snatch’d me to the skies,
E’er vice triumphant had possess’d my heart,
E’er yet the tempter had beguil’d my heart,
E’er yet on sin’s base actions I was bent,
E’er yet I knew temptation’s dire intent;
E’er yet the lash for horrid crimes I felt,
E’er vanity had led my way to guilt,
But, soon arriv’d at my celestial goal,
Full glories rush on my expanding soul.”
Joyful he spoke: exulting cherubs round
Clapt their glad wings, the heav’nly vaults resound.

Say, parents, why this unavailing moan?
Why heave your pensive bosoms with the groan?
To Charles, the happy subject of my song,
A brighter world, and nobler strains belong.
Say would you tear him from the realms above
By thoughtless wishes, and prepost’rous love?
Doth his felicity increase your pain?
Or could you welcome to this world again
The heir of bliss? with a superior air
Methinks he answers with a smile severe,
“Thrones and dominions cannot tempt me there.”
But still you cry, “Can we the sigh forbear,
And still and still must we not pour the tear?
Our only hope, more dear than vital breath,
Twelve moons revolv’d, becomes the prey of death;
Delightful infant, nightly visions give 
Thee to our arms, and we with joy receive,
We fain would clasp the Phantom to our breast,
The Phantom flies, and leaves the soul unblest.”

To yon bright regions let your faith ascend,
Prepare to join your dearest infant friend
In pleasures without measure, without end.

On seeing a deceased infant

As I guess is the domain of the life-long literary scholar, in my grief I have turned to literature for comfort, as well as curiosity. I have begun to think about how dead or dying children have been portrayed in literature throughout the ages - to reflect on what I already know about this theme in nineteenth-century fiction, like that of Dickens, and to seek out answers to what I don't know, which is a lot. During my reading, I've come across a couple of lovely poems, which I want to share here. I'll come back to my research in another post, at another time, after I've read much more widely. But here is a poem. The last stanza made me cry.

On Seeing a Deceased Infant
By William B. O. Peabody (1799–1847)

AND this is death! how cold and still,
And yet how lovely it appears!
Too cold to let the gazer smile,
But far too beautiful for tears.
The sparkling eye no more is bright,
The cheek hath lost its rose-like red;
And yet it is with strange delight
I stand and gaze upon the dead.

But when I see the fair wide brow,
Half shaded by the silken hair, 
That never look’d so fair as now,
When life and health were laughing there
I wonder not that grief should swell
So wildly upward in the breast,
And that strong passion once rebel
That need not, cannot be suppress’d.

I wonder not that parents’ eyes
In gazing thus grow cold and dim,
That burning tears and aching sighs
Are blended with the funeral hymn; 
The spirit hath an earthly part,
That weeps when earthly pleasure flies,
And heaven would scorn the frozen heart
That melts not when the infant dies.

And yet why mourn? that deep repose
Shall never more be broke by pain;
Those lips no more in sighs unclose,
Those eyes shall never weep again.
For think not that the blushing flower
Shall wither in the church-yard sod,
’T was made to gild an angel’s bower
Within the paradise of God.

Once more I gaze—and swift and far
The clouds of death in sorrow fly,
I see thee like a new-born star 
Move up thy pathway in the sky:
The star hath rays serene and bright,
But cold and pale compared with thine;
For thy orb shines with heavenly light,
With beams unfailing and divine. 

Then let the burthen’d heart be free,
The tears of sorrow all be shed,
And parents calmly bend to see
The mournful beauty of the dead;
Thrice happy—that their infant bears
To heaven no darkening stains of sin;
And only breathed life’s morning airs
Before its evening storms begin.

Farewell! I shall not soon forget!
Although thy heart hath ceased to beat, 
My memory warmly treasures yet
Thy features calm and mildly sweet;
But no, that look is not the last,
We yet may meet where seraphs dwell,
Where love no more deplores the past, 
Nor breathes that withering word—farewell.

Six months in a leaky boat


Thursday 24th May, 2012, marked six sorrowful months since my beloved baby was born.

That I'm still living and breathing is something I could not have imagined possible in the beginning.

That my body, which created him, could go on functioning, though he could not, is something that both troubles and amazes me in equal measure.

Surely, that I am still here despite my gaping, immeasurably septic wound, is evidence of how driven and intent our bodies are for survival. Yet, this same instinct of self-preservation was of no use to little Max, whose body was not strong enough to cooperate with the desperate wishes of his parents, his family, and his friends, who prayed, even if they didn't believe in prayer, for his survival.

Why does it take 40 weeks for a baby to develop and grow in readiness for life on earth, but the space of less than 24 hours for the same system that so magically kept him alive to systematically deconstruct and expel him, without explanation, from the very place he was supposed to be safest?

If we can cure cancer, and turn the clock back on AIDS, and give someone a new heart, liver or face, and if we can rocket into space and map our every whereabouts with mysterious, all-seeing satellites, and if we can restore hearing to the deaf, and manufacture cars that tell you how many kilometres you can go before you run out of petrol, how can we not save the life of a 23 week old baby who seems just as healthy and 'complete' as any full term baby, but who is just a little on the small side?

How can we allow the death of a baby whose life had not even begun, who never even got to open his eyes and see his mother's face, when we strenuously defend the right to life of the most hardened, evil murderers?

How can we expect a mother of a desperately-wanted baby to go home from the hospital without him and start her life again as if nothing had ever happened; as if she were still the same person she ever was, with the same hopes she ever had?

We don't know how we can, but we do.

And six months after that, when we ask her how she is, we expect her to be able to say 'not bad, thanks, how are you?' whether she really means it or not, so we can stop feeling bad that our own lives have gone on while hers is suspended in a time she thinks she still might be able to get back to, if only she tries hard enough.

Why can't she be happy for us when we announce our own happy pregnancies or births? It's not all about her, we think. We want her to be interested in us again, in our own domestic ups and downs, but she just doesn't seem to care. We can't say the right thing, so we don't bother saying anything at all about that unfortunate baby boy anymore. We instead talk to her about how we know someone, who knows someone, who had a miscarriage or a stillborn baby, and who went on to have more children, and who was happy, and how shouldn't that give her hope for the future?

And after all, we think to ourselves, although we'd never say that it out loud, was he even a real baby anyway? Plenty of people lose babies - what ever that deeply mysterious process means or entails - and move on. Why can't she? Except that we've never seen a baby at 23 weeks gestation, heard him gasp for air, and felt his tiny heart beating with frantic gusto, so perhaps we think that somehow he was a less valuable to lose than our own animated earthly babies, whose deaths, after being undeniably, publicly, alive, would be so much more devastating; would be a much more legitimate trauma.

We continue to gaily announce our joyous pregnancies and births to her, often with little regard to how she might receive the news. Of course we tell her how blessed we feel at the miracle of our baby's healthy birth, lest she think we are ungrateful, and perhaps to assuage the guilt we feel at our good fortune. But she doesn't hear gratitude in our voices, she hears relief that we did not suffer her unfortunate fate. She hears that for some reason we think God chose to bestow specific blessings on us but she decided to leave her out of it. It might not make sense now, we tell her, but one day it will. Things always happen for a reason.

But she knows they don't. That's an elaborate lie we tell ourselves in order to better endure our sufferings. The earth does not have a master plan. And even if it did, why should we, inconsequential dots in a sea of humanity, expect to rate a mention in it?

We talk to her occasionally and think she seems more hopeful, and brighter of voice, and we're relieved that we might get to stop thinking of, and talking about, dead babies soon. But all the while, as she listens to us talk about how she should be hopeful for the future,  she still doesn't accept that she's not even pregnant anymore. She still wears her maternity clothes in the vain hope that one day she'll look down and see that they're still filled out after all, that it was all just a terrible dream.

For she's spent six months in a leaky boat and she still doesn't believe that the life she once dreamed of is sinking further and further to the bottom of the ocean as each day, week, month passes. Every day, when she wakes up, she starts slowly and surely bailing out the stinging, salty water all over again, just keeping afloat, with the cruel glimpse of dry land in the distance, but no way of knowing if she'll make it there, or even what she'll do if she does.

Six months after her baby is born, this tired mother closes down the tens of tabs on her internet browser, on which she's spent so much time comparing the merits of various infant cremation urns from around the world, and chooses one, which she ships with the help of a friend in America.

It arrives, and it is the one she took six months to decided upon, but she suddenly loathes the sight of it. The brass teddy bear on the front looks garish and zombified. The finish is a little too shiny. The wood stain is more reddish than it should have been; too bright and gaudy. It's got a chip on the corner obtained during the perils of international shipping. It is flawed in ways the boy whose ashes it will carry never was; never could have been.

She could buy every single cremation urn from every single crevice of the earth, and none of them would be worthy of holding her perfect child. There is no suitable way to keep his remains that befits his beauty, his delicacy, his innocence, except to wrap them in his baby blanket, tuck them under her arm, and never let them go.

As the six month mark passes she feels she's come so far. And yet sometimes it feels like six months is nothing at all. That she's still at the beginning, with so far to go.


On Miscarriage

You should read this haunting, lyrical piece about a miscarriage - perhaps the loveliest, but most upsetting I've read.

I found it because I was thinking of what it must be like to experience a miscarriage. Recently I participated in a focus group at SANDS, which reviewed the infant death literature they provide to newly bereaved parents. In a follow up email, the facilitator who was in charge of creating the new booklets, emailed me to ask if, perchance, I'd also suffered a miscarriage, as she was having trouble finding women to give feedback on their miscarriage brochures. I didn't take offence - she was just asking what was from her perspective a pragmatic question, but it made me wonder about why she thought I might have been a likely candidate. Perhaps she thought I was more likely to have given that I'd had a baby who died? Or perhaps she didn't think that through at all, but was just trying to get her brochures finished on time.

At any rate, I never really feared miscarriage when I was pregnant with Max, although I knew from everything I'd ever been read or told that it is quite common in the early stages of a pregnancy. I was relieved when I passed the symbolic 12 week mark, though, I guess. Except I now see how pointless that so-called magical milestone is. Women are encouraged not to tell anyone they're pregnant before this time because the vast majority of miscarriages occur within the first trimester. I have two problems with this. The first is that this implies if you did lose a baby it's something shameful that you wouldn't want people to know about. The second is that it produces this kind of false reassurance that if you get through the first trimester with no problems then it's smooth sailing from there in. I had no idea my baby could up and die half way through my pregnancy for no good reason. I really don't think we should perpetuate this myth of certainty. It's not fair, and most importantly, it's not true. Yes, you're less statistically likely to lose your baby after the first trimester, but you're certainly don't become magically less immune to the possibility.

Leslie and I have wondered how we would cope if I were pregnant again and had a miscarriage early on. We can't help but think about it. It's like Heineman mentions in the article: you kind of assume that you're destined for the trifecta - miscarriage, stillbirth, infant death - when you've had one of them happen to you and you know for sure now that your name is on at least one, and maybe more tickets in the dead baby lottery.

The dead baby lottery: when you're the winner

It upsets me to think about miscarriage because it makes me think of people, like the writer of the article I mentioned, alone and afraid losing their baby at home. It makes me feel sick that a small fetus might be accidentally flushed down the toilet. It makes me angry that mother's who miscarry don't get any official recognition that their baby existed (in fact, you get no recognition of your baby unless they are over 20 weeks gestation, which is a baby who is undeniably human and perfectly formed at that stage).

I hope I never have to find out what that feels like.

I hope that the dead baby lottery is like a pass-the-parcel game at a children's birthday party, and that the music isn't allowed to stop on you if you've already had a turn - just so that it's fair for everyone.

But it's not fair for everyone, is it? Some people, like Heineman, will experience the loss of multiple babies. Others, who perhaps take reckless risks during their pregnancies, or who are not fit parents, will continue to get to keep their babies, defying any sense of the rationality and reason we assume operates in our world.

There's no rationality and reason at all, though, really. There's no such thing as your 'fair share' or 'taking it in turns', or 'lightning doesn't strike twice, or 'you've suffered enough'. 'There are no rewards for being a good person, or for doing the right thing, despite what every parent, teacher or church will tell you to the contrary. There is just randomness and chaos; a universe in disarray, in which we are but the smallest, most inconsequential inhabitants. It's catch-cry is 'shit happens: don't take it personally'.

Thursday, May 24, 2012

Grief reactions

Today on Daily Life, Sarah Wayland writes about grief survivors - people who have suffered unimaginable losses and who, despite all their feelings to the contrary, have survived and gone on to create new meaning in their life as a consequence of their experiences.


This idea of resilience in the face of tragedy is very inspiring, and I agree with Mal McKissock (the co-Director of the Bereavement Care Centre) when he says that the majority of people who've suffered a traumatic loss manage to keep moving forward, even if they don't want to, however I do think the concept of resilience is much more complicated than how the article presents it.

Wayland asks the important question of how realistic it is to assume that people can choose to react in a resilient way when faced with loss, but never really answers it, except to say that attitudes toward resilience are complicated by issues of time. Resilience in the fact of tragedy is encouraged and celebrated in the longer term, as with the stories of Ingrid Poulson and Bruce Morcombe, she suggests, but is perceived as strange or abnormal immediately after a loss, in the period we associate with intense grief and sadness.  

The article acknowledges that there is no 'right' way to grieve - a message that I am keen to promote. I am glad to find the media engaging with issues of bereavement, but time and time again the things I read do leave me wondering what people who are suffering and not coping, particularly long after a tragedy, think when they read these things. While they're told on one level that there's no 'right' way to grieve, it is the constant promulgation of what I like to call 'happy hero' stories that tell them on a on another level that their grief is 'wrong'. The constant reporting of 'hero' stories tell those people, however unconsciously, that if they haven't been able to move on, or integrate the experience in their lives in psychologically pleasing ways, or if they give up or fall apart or otherwise spectacularly destroy themselves, that they are somehow less remarkable or that they are failures.

In actuality, to still be walking and talking and breathing after suffering a tragedy of the magnitude those mentioned in the story have, is, I think, to have already surpassed expectation. Can we not also acknowledge the battlers? The ones that might never be able to recover or re-frame their experience in positive ways? The ones for whom making it to the shower on any given day, or opening the blinds, is every bit an achievement as returning to work, or running a foundation, or marrying again?

I consider myself to be very fortunate in the amount of support and assistance I've had in rebuilding my sense of self, and my life, after Max died. I still feel as if I've taken only a few steps down the road to resilience, but I know I have the capacity for it. I feel hopeful that I will be courageous enough to try for another child, and on some days I am able to see beyond by grief to witness a glimpse of what the future may hold. I am acutely aware, however, that for some people all of this seems about as impossible as spacewalking to the moon.

One of the most powerful things about a recent episode of Insight I wrote about, which dealt with grief, was its inclusion of people for whom life has not begun again in earnest, but who were crippled with grief, sometimes years after the loss of their loved one. We hope that the bereaved can find peace and hope again, of course, and those who have should be rightly celebrated. But let us also acknowledge those for whom the road ahead seems as bleak and as impossible as it did in the first days after their loss. Let us not forget the courage that it takes for them to just wake up every morning with the memory of their traumatic loss so fresh in their head. That's resilience.

How is grief today?

I made a new friend this week, someone with whom I seem to have a lot in common. We are both lapsed PhD students, and were sent on somewhat of a blind date after being put in touch by my thesis supervisor. We had many helpful conversations about our PhD journeys, but it turns out that along the way we have each experienced the profound grief of losing a loved one; in her case a boyfriend, in my case a child.

Speaking to someone who has had to face death head on is something I don't get to do very often, as most of the people I know are fortunate, as I was until recently, to be still naively unaware of death's very real and pernicious impact. Also, not everyone who has lost a loved one embraces grief and opens themselves up to its ravages as I have. Some people I've known have, conversely, let grief shut them down, and consequently you get the sense when talking to those people that they don't really want to be fully present in your experience either because your very visible and unapologetic grief perhaps threatens to make them reflect on the feelings they've very carefully and deliberately locked away in the unconscious recesses of their mind.

To talk to someone who was willing and able to share, and reflect upon their own experience of grief, in all its messy realities, was so valuable. Sometimes strangers, I've found, are willing to sit with you as you describe your suffering in a way that people close to you find it too difficult and painful to do. We discussed a lot of things that seem to happen when you are mourning someone who has died: the distorted sense of time that messes with your mind, your inability to focus or concentrate on anything, the sense that all about you is fleeting and temporary, the sleep disturbances, the pools and pools of tears, the tumult of emotions that oscillate from the very internally experienced emotions of  regret, guilt, and disbelief to the very external experience of anger and bitterness and injustice.

During our two-hour conversation I felt, powerfully, heard.

In a follow up email this very wise woman asked me the simplest yet most thought-provoking question: how is grief today? The question is an evocative one, and in four simple words, that anyone can utter, does a number of really important things. It recognises that grief is something that stays with you all the time, even on the days when you're back at work and wearing a smile, and thinking of the future, in short, on the days when most people think you've 'recovered'.

Secondly, it recognises that grief is not one experience, but an umbrella term under which a person has many experiences, both physically and emotionally. On some days grief feels like a heavy burden to shoulder, and one you're keen to get rid of, and on others it feels like a badge of honour you carry on behalf of your loved one; that your grief will ensure their immortality.

The question also recognises that grief occupies its own very real space - it is personified by the question very accurately as either a companion or an appendage. As time goes by, you are able sometimes to put grief away as you would a favourite book on a shelf, having memorised and internalised some parts so that it is always a part of you, and having the other parts bookmarked and archived somewhere discrete and separate to you, but which you can visit or call upon at any time. As time goes by I've noticed that grief becomes more malleable - you can move it around, put it down, look at it from different angles, change its face, or bathe in it. You begin to learn to wield it and tame it and direct it, though of course sometimes it still rears up like an angry beast, pins you to the floor, as asserts its authority. It's just that it does so less often.

So, how is grief today? It's anxious, mostly, and interfering with my sleep by intruding in the form of horrible nightmares in which various members of my family die painfully and I am unable to stop it. It's not that these dreams are new - anxious nightmares of being abandoned are really my thing. I used to have a recurring nightmare that I was on a ship with my family and one by one they all drowned, whilst I ran around trying to save them, and always turning up a moment too late. It's just that those dreams are scarier now that I'm very conscious of the fact that any one I love really can, and one day will, just up and die, despite any intervention on my part. Confronting Max's death means I can no longer sooth myself with platitudes such as 'it was only a dream, just a silly nightmare' because I know that sometimes the stuff of those nightmares does emerge in your waking life, and is all the more frightening because you know yourself to already be awake.

Grief today is also dragging and exhausting in a way it hasn't been for at least a couple of weeks. I haven't moved from the couch today. I feel sat upon by something very heavy and suffocating, and it is not my cat. I can't seem to muster the energy to do anything except nap on and off, which is in contrast to the active, busy way I've managed to get things done recently. I feel that I may be coming down with something, but I also know this is probably not true and that this exhaustion is all just a part of the cycle to be endured.

Often grief is quiet and insular, as it is today. It makes me unable to tolerate any noise and unwilling to talk to anyone if I can get away from it. It craves silence and inactivity, and on those days, when all else is quiet, it is ever present in its guise as intense sadness and regretful reflection.

Today grief forces me to huddle under a blanket and sink into the soft furnishings, where I'll stay until it comes tomorrow with a new face.


Things-I-Love-Thursday: Audible

When I was pregnant with Max last year I was so sick that I couldn't do anything. The seriousness of my nausea and vomiting will hit home to you when I tell you that I could not even read - the one thing I can usually take comfort from no matter what I'm going through. So much time spent in bed, so many potential reading hours wasted. I am one of those people who gets genuinely upset when I realise how few books one can manage to read in a lifetime, even though I get through a lot more than the average person, so to reflect on lost reading time is an actual tragedy for me!

I wish I'd known this time last year of the wonderful invention that is Audible. Kate told me about it recently after hearing of its advantages on one of the many podcasts she listens to as she walks her dog. Audible is basically an online store that lets you subscribe to buy audio books, and it is a wonderful, exciting find!

It's 'reading' for when you can't actually read. Such as when you are driving (lord knows I've tried), vomiting, in labour, or simply when you have your hands full of cake, which I know is a problem we all face.

Audible's audio books aren't just a substitute for actual books, though. The pleasure of being read to is one that is rich and valuable in itself, and regrettably rare when you are an adult. I find nothing more soothing than being read to, although I can't remember the last time someone in my actual life did this for me. Just saying, the position is open for volunteers!

I'm clearly an aurally-oriented person as even in general life I am very sensitive to people's tones of voices and accents, for example. My first download from Audible was over 40 hours worth of Charles Dickens' Our Mutual Friend (unabridged), read by a professional voice actor which a gloriously pommy English accent. Sometimes I love listening to it so much that it lulls me into some kind of reverie and when I emerge I realise I've missed two chapters of plot happenings. In the case of Our Mutual Friend this is quite problematic as it is a book I have been trying to get through for about five years, to no avail. I thought listening to it in audio form was the answer, but it seems I'm doomed never to find out what's really hiding in Harmon's dust heaps.

Audible is a subsidiary of Amazon, so it is no surprise that the breadth of its offerings is quite impressive. According to Wikipedia, Audible holds over 100,000 titles, which is a hell of a hours spent in boring car trips that can now be spent productively. And it's not just the classics that are catered for. You can get all the latest bestsellers, including The Hunger Games, which all the school children are talking about. Kate's first purchase was Tina Fey's autobiography, Bossypants, read by none other than Tina Fey herself, which is reason enough to buy it in my opinion. I don't know how often authors narrate their own work, but I like it. I've recently downloaded Toni Morrison's Beloved, even though I've already read it, just because Toni Morrison has narrated it herself. I feel there must be something extra to get from a story when it is read by the person who dreamed its rhythms, and I can't wait to listen to it.

Audible have a number of very attractive membership plans (and no, I'm not being paid to say this), and you can sign up to a special free trial as a new subscriber, after which they offer you three months at half price, which is the deal I am currently taking advantage of.

So, get ye to Audible and download yourself a tome for your next road trip, I say.

And to finish, here is a very interesting article I recently read in the New York Times about the pleasures and sorrows of reading in the car. Enjoy!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...